By Rita C. Aguilar,
ABA State Legislative Counsel
Assisted by Cathleen McCarroll, ABA Program Assistant
As the popularity of on-line resources continues to grow, state
bars and lawyer disciplinary agencies across the country have begun
utilizing the Internet as a tool for posting lawyer disciplinary
information on their web sites. The type of information posted on
these sites can include disciplinary sanctions, as well as, in some
instances, copies of the opinions or orders imposing the discipline.
According to Jim Grogan, President of the National Organization
of Bar Counsel, in a world where many people get much of their information
from the Internet, this evolving practice can help make information
more accessible to the general public and increase public trust
and confidence in the legal profession.
The American Bar Association has long supported public access to
lawyer disciplinary information. For example, the ABA's Commission
on Evaluation of Lawyer Disciplinary Enforcement (McKay Commission)
stated in their 1992 report,
Lawyer Regulation for A New Century Report of the Commission
on Evaluation of Disciplinary Enforcement, "All records
of the lawyer disciplinary agency except the work product of disciplinary
counsel should be available to the public after a determination
has been made that probable cause exists to believe misconduct occurred,
unless the complainant or respondent obtains a protective order
from the highest court or its designee for specific testimony, documents
or records." This policy is also set forth in Rule 16 of the
ABA
Model Rules for Lawyer Disciplinary Enforcement.
To date, as many as twenty-nine jurisdictions have followed this
movement toward electronic communications and maintain an Internet
link to lawyer disciplinary information, including: Arkansas, Arizona,
California, Colorado, Connecticut, District of Columbia, Florida,
Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan,
Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, North Carolina,
North Dakota, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Vermont,
Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming.
The ABA's Center for Professional Responsibility
also maintains a directory
of lawyer disciplinary agencies.